Someone just played that against me for the first time yesterday. I responded with 1. ... e6, then just went for natural king side development (Nf6, Be7, 0-0) and played d5 early. I got a reasonable game out of it, though that pawn sitting on b5 most of the game did limit me a little, since I couldn't get my knight out to c6.
--Fromper
Ok, now this thread has me thinking about my own openings. As I said, I play the Blackmar-Diemer Gambit, and I get good games when my opponents avoid the gambit, but I just realized that in my tournament games where my opponents actually played the gambit, I haven't won a game yet! 4 losses and a draw!
The author of the book I bought on the gambit says that playing it for a year or so against a wide variety of opponents is a good way to improve to around 1800 (USCF), because it'll teach you how to attack, so I was planning on sticking with it even though I'm not doing well with it initially. The whole point of my switching to playing gambits was the "learn to attack or die trying" method of learning. But it really only just occurred to me that I do so poorly with it in the actual gambit lines.
Now I'm seriously considering coming full circle and switching back to the Colle...
--Fromper
It's quite funny really, Fromper. I read a few of your posts and started playing the Blackmar-Diemar and have had a lot of success with it.
I don't know what it is, but my opponents seem to improvise well against it. I really haven't played it that many times, as many of my opponents avoid it, and I tend to get good positions when that happens. For instance, this last weekend, I played a tournament game where I tried to play the BDG and we transposed into the French (1. d4 Nf6 2. Nc3 e6 3. e4 d5), but my opponent didn't know how to play the French properly, so I won pretty easily. And the 5 games I was refering to are USCF tournament games. In practice games on the internet, I've had some wins.
But as I said, the book I'm using as my reference on the BDG says that playing it regularly will be a good learning experience. I think it's right, since I really am learning a little bit every time I play it. I think I need a second opening to play regularly, though, as I tend to play the same dozen or so people in tournaments the most often, so they're likely to prepare for it once they know I play it.
--Fromper