common it doesnt make sense at all you sort them by random so why you gave number please be clear.. and i cant see any players like ivancuk or kares or botvinnik....
Top 10 Players of All Time
I already posted this in a similar topic, but in case you haven't read it here's my list:
Top 10 Chess Players in Order of Best to Worst:
1. My cat
2. The ice cream man
3. The author of The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy
4. Sir Gawain
5. Frodo Baggins
6. The actor that played Frodo Baggins
7. A pack of peanut M&Ms
8. Barack Obama
9. Garry Kasparov
10. Rybka
17 1/2. Me (because that's my lucky number)
1. Hydra (the game with Adams was a public slaughter)/ Rybka (familiar to many)
2. Deep Blue Mk II (I like that it didn't blink...ever)
3. Kasparov (universal player, I see so much Alekhine in him)
4. Anand (see Kramnik)
5. Topalov (pure chess playing machine)
6. Kramnik (along with Anand, the best positional player at the moment)
7. Ivanchuk (i still can't get a hold of his style)
8. Carlsen (playing strength near 2800 and still so young)
9. Shirov/Morozevich (because they showed me how chess is played on Mars)
10. Fischer (because it will make everybody happy:))
1. Hydra (the game with Adams was a public slaughter)/ Rybka (familiar to many)
2. Deep Blue Mk II (I like that it didn't blink...ever)
3. Kasparov (universal player, I see so much Alekhine in him)
4. Anand (see Kramnik)
5. Topalov (pure chess playing machine)
6. Kramnik (along with Anand, the best positional player at the moment)
7. Ivanchuk (i still can't get a hold of his style)
8. Carlsen (playing strength near 2800 and still so young)
9. Shirov/Morozevich (because they showed me how chess is played on Mars)
10. Fischer (because it will make everybody happy:))
Rybka eats Hydra alive anyday... everyday..
that´s how little fish roll
Top eight tacticians of all time(my opinion):
1. Tal
2. Nezhmetdinov
3. Alekhine
4. Fischer
5. Kasparov
6. Karpov
7. Anderssen
8. Morphy
so i don't actually play chess, but i like this history stuff. so there is no consences on the greatest player of all time? there's no michael phelps of chess? and also another q, when a world champion plays the world's smartest computer, who wins?
oinquarki - I think your inclusion of Frodo Baggins is much deserved and all I can say is: It's about time the little people get some respect!!
jntrcs: Like most disciplines, the champions of the past 50 years are better than the champions of the previous 50 years. And within the past 50 years, the most recent 25 years are the strongest. So this would leave us, in theory, with the question of "who is the current strongest player". But that leaves aside G. Kasparov, who may not be the current strongest player (because he is not up-to-date on the current theoretical discussions in the openings) but is most likely the strongest player of all time.
The strongest computer is better than the strongest human, and it's not really that close.
nezhmetdinov is way the best tactical player , so for me
1. Nezhmetdinov
2. Kasparov
3. Capablanca
4. Anthony Mies
Who cares for the rest? :P
Top ten? In terms of match-playing ability, I reckon:
Garry Kasparov
Anatoly Karpov
Emmanuel Lasker
Bobby Fischer
Mikhail Botvinnik
Viktor Korchnoi
Tigran Petrosian
Boris Spassky
Jose Capablanca
Vishwanathan Anand
Though the modern players are probably stronger in absolute terms with the advancement of chess theory, etc.
1. Fischer
2. Kasparov
3. Capablanca
4. Tal
5. Karpov
6. Anand
7. Morphy
8. Kramnik
9. Lasker
10. Chigorin/Alekhine